About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Golf Chat Paves Way for ICE-Apollo Breakthrough in Private Credit Data Transparency

Subscribe to our newsletter

The latest expansion of ICE’s private markets provisions can be partly traced back to a game of golf that Chris Edmonds, President of ICE’s Fixed Income and Data Services, had more than two years ago with the corporate treasurer of a large insurance company.

As play progressed, talk turned to data provisioning for private credit investors, in which insurance companies are big backers.

The discussion highlighted how institutional investors were allocating huge amounts of capital, essentially, on trust because they had been unable to gauge with any degree of accuracy or consistency the performance of their investments. Without the transparency offered by even the most basic of economic terms that would be included in a loan’s documents, they concluded, it would be impossible to assess value and pricing of the instruments.

“It was hard to believe that a market as sophisticated as private credit was missing key components that everyone could understand,” Edmonds told Data Management Insight.

That conversation was the spark that set in train 15 months of research between ICE and alternative investments giant Apollo Capital Solutions to establish how investors in private credit could gain the same level of transparency into their loans as holders of publicly available credit.

“We agreed that fundamentally what was missing was a foundational reference data layer,” Edmonds said. “We showed them how we develop independent third-party pricing for the public credit side daily then began applying very similar metrics to the private credit data side, which started to show where the gaps in that data were, and the increased granularity that was available.”

The fruits of that process were unveiled in the summer in the form of ICE IDs, one of the latest enhancements to the company’s ICE Private Credit Intelligence offering. ICE IDs are unique persistent identifiers for private credit instruments, offering vital information at the loan level. They provide a means to link together all the critical reference data associated with private credit issuances so that investors can follow them through their investment lifecycle from origination to final payoff date and closure. Importantly, they provide a benchmark for pricing the instruments and evaluating the prices of issuances similar to them.

Data Difficulties

Despite the traditional opacity of private markets, data isn’t in short supply – the bottleneck has long been the inability or reluctance of general partners (GPs), who allocate capital on behalf of their investors, to gather and use it. Often locked away in unstructured form within PDFs, messages and even handwritten notebooks, extracting and formatting that data has become a focus of vendors and technology providers alike. That’s especially so as institutions have become among the largest group of LPs; an estimated third of their capital is funnelled into private equity, private credit, property and other once illiquid instruments.

The importance of data-savvy institutions to the market has led to a slew of incumbents and start-ups offering services to tame the private data beast with public market-like capabilities. The most recent was the embedding of artificial intelligence into S&P Global’s iLEVEL private markets platform for portfolio monitoring, valuations, reporting and data management. Other vendors offering private and alternative markets capabilities include Alkymi, Nasdaq, CUSIP and MSCI.

Reference Data

ICE IDs are built on the company’s expertise in reference data provision, which covers 35 million financial instruments over 210 markets. The foundation of its reference data business was put in place with the acquisition of Interactive Data Corporation in 2015. Apollo has contributed deal-level data relating to 7,500-plus deals, totalling more than US$1.3 trillion in notional cover data.

The IDs data layer is standardised, secure and permissioned enabling deal-level information to be shared with authorised counterparties while keeping proprietary data safe. Utilising ICE’s technology stack, it also permits the scalable extraction of data and provides a distribution model for ingesting deal documents, extracting key terms and data points and distributing secured, consistent information at scale.

The data challenge in private credit is daunting. Each loan deal’s documentation can contain as many as 1,000 economic terms that are meaningful to the transaction, said Edmonds. Of those, 450 can be updated each quarter and around 65 can be revised on a weekly or daily basis.

But there are between 20 and 25 terms that are absolutely critical for investors wanting to query those instruments on a secondary trading venue; that is a lot of information that GPs have traditionally struggled to gather.

With the help of ICE’s own AI models, which are trained on public credit deals, ICE IDs have been created to capture bespoke economic terms found in loan documentation.

“What we’ve done is we’ve taken that stratification and built a data product based on certain levels of granularity that people can now purchase,” said Edmonds.

More Transparency

The private credit market – and broader private assets market – has become more transparent as institutional money has surged into it. While ICE IDs aren’t yet capable of capturing all the same sort of data for private loans as it can for publicly traded loans, Edmonds said that goal isn’t far off.

“Things have to become more transparent; I believe those who’ve been in the market long enough know that transparency will ultimately win,” he said.

At the moment ICE’s plans for its IDs offering is to add more datasets and take an iterative approach to its development. Edmonds, however, sees the space evolving constantly and to a degree that will bring data provisioning in private markets to a similar level to that in public markets.

“I do believe that in the future… you will get an independent third-party price like you do in public markets that you can have a lot more confidence in because you now have the exact audit trail from what elements drove that ultimate price that you’re getting,” he said.

“We’re not trying to be revolutionary. You can be too early to market structure change. We’re trying to let the customers lead as they want increased transparency and velocity. We can give them the tools to do that.”

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: The Data Office at a Crossroads — AI Governance, Organisational Design, and the Evolving Mandate of the CDO

Who owns AI governance in a capital markets firm – and is the Data Office structured to bear that weight? These questions sit at the heart of A-Team Research’s latest findings, presented here for the first time: the combined results of two landmark surveys examining the role of the Data Office in AI governance and...

BLOG

Dasseti Acquisition Provides New Private Markets ‘Chapter’ for Nasdaq

Nasdaq’s acquisition of Dasseti, a due diligence and monitoring platform, extends the exchange and data company’s interests in private markets and highlights the growing importance of the sector to capital markets investors. The deal, which was completed in September, will see the artificial intelligence-powered tools of Dasseti integrated into Nasdaq’s eVestment business, and rolled out across...

EVENT

RegTech Summit New York

Now in its 10th year, the RegTech Summit in New York will bring together the RegTech ecosystem to explore how the North American capital markets financial industry can leverage technology to drive innovation, cut costs and support regulatory change.

GUIDE

Data Lineage Handbook

Data lineage has become a critical concern for data managers in capital markets as it is key to both regulatory compliance and business opportunity. The regulatory requirement for data lineage kicked in with BCBS 239 in 2016 and has since been extended to many other regulations that oblige firms to provide transparency and a data...