The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

ESMA Finally Puts Its Foot Down on Consolidated Ticker Tape

The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) has bitten the bullet on a real-time consolidated ticker tape for European equities, following the failure of an industry-led solution to emerge. In a review of market data pricing published today, the regulator warns that market data costs under MiFID II are still too high, confirming plans to step in with the creation of a mandatory EU-wide solution.

“Transparency is important to ensure that markets are fair, sound and efficient. However, after nearly two years of operating under MIFID II, we are still lacking a reliable view of liquidity across the EU,” notes ESMA Chair Steven Maijoor. “Therefore, we need to establish a real-time consolidated tape for equity instruments to remedy the fragmentation of EU markets, create a real single market and so contribute to the establishment of the Capital Markets Union.”

MiFID II requires venues and data providers to publish market data on a reasonable commercial basis, provide market data in a disaggregated format, and to make market data available free of charge 15 minutes after publication with the objective to lower the cost for market data. However, implementation has not been entirely successful and although most trading venues claim that data prices have been overall stable, data users and vendors have complained about excessive fees, complex market data policies and overall higher costs for data.

In response to these concerns, earlier this year ESMA conducted a consultation on the need for a consolidated tape, to which responses were varied. Broadly, financial services firms and data users are largely in favour – with organisations such as the International Securities Market Association (ISMA) coming out in support. Exchanges and some data vendors, however, responded with significantly less enthusiasm – the World Federation of Exchanges, for example, objecting that: “Price-setting by the official sector is an extreme policy tool that can only be justified in extraordinary circumstances.”

Despite the mixed industry feedback, it looks as if the ayes have it. “Access to market data is becoming increasingly important for securities markets and it is important that data users know what they are paying for,” says Maijoor. “ESMA will therefore provide further guidance on the cost of market data.”

According to ESMA, a market-led initiative failed to thrive due to the limited commercial rewards available to potential providers within the current regulatory framework, as well as possible competition by non-regulated entities such as data vendors. It therefore recommends the mandatory contribution of data by trading venues and APAs, as well as a revenue-sharing model between contributing entities. To succeed where the industry has failed, it proposes a mix of both legislative changes and supervisory guidance to improve transparency and to ensure that market data is provided on a reasonable commercial basis.

However, there are no illusions as to the mammoth size of the task ahead, and ESMA admits that the process is likely to be both time-consuming and technically demanding, requiring a “substantial investment” of both time and resources by all parties involved.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Market data management, licensing and administration in the post-Covid environment

Market data administration has always been a challenge. For many firms, keeping tabs on permissioning and entitlements, compliance with licensing agreements, and reconciling all that with increasingly complex invoices requires a significant dedicated resource with a clear understanding of the issues involved. As if that weren’t enough, things got more challenging for these teams in...

BLOG

Refinitiv Teams with MarketPsych to Launch ESG Analytics

Continuing its focus on adding capabilities with an ESG theme, Refinitiv has teamed up with Los Angeles-based MarketPsych to launch Refinitiv MarketPsych ESG Analytics to monitor perceptions of sustainability and ESG risk. The analytical tool draws upon news and social media monitoring to offer analysts and portfolio managers numerical insights into companies and countries of...

EVENT

Data Management Summit London

The Data Management Summit Virtual explores how financial institutions are shifting from defensive to offensive data management strategies, to improve operational efficiency and revenue enhancing opportunities. We’ll be putting the business lens on data and deep diving into the data management capabilities needed to deliver on business outcomes.

GUIDE

MiFID II Handbook – Second Edition

With the compliance deadline for Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II) just over two months away, A-Team Group has updated its MiFID II handbook to bring you the latest details on the regulation’s compliance requirements. Version 2 of the handbook, commissioned by Thomson Reuters, also includes new sections covering data sourcing and data...