About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

FCA Reviews IPFR as Board Assessments and Regulatory Returns Diverge

Subscribe to our newsletter

In November 2025, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) reported that it regularly found substantial differences between figures in investment firms’ annual returns and the capital and liquidity assessments their boards had approved. On 18 November 2026, the FCA opened a call for input on the UK’s Investment Firms Prudential Regime (IFPR). Drawing on its supervisory work and feedback from firms, the regulator wants to establish how well those assessments reflect the way firms manage risk and where clearer rules would help.

About 3,000 firms fall under the regime, including wholesale brokers and wealth managers. Through the Internal Capital Adequacy and Risk Assessment (ICARA), each firm determines how much capital and liquidity it needs to protect clients and markets, including during an orderly wind-down. Firms report the results to the FCA in their annual MIF007 return.

Revisiting the Regime

When the UK introduced the IPFR in January 2022, it replaced 11 prudential categories with a framework designed around the harm an investment firm could cause its clients and the markets in which it operates. The regime predates the FCA’s secondary objective on international competitiveness and growth. Nearly five years on, the FCA says its work supervising firms and assessing authorisation applications, together with feedback from industry, has identified parts of the regime that firms find difficult to apply. Its 18 November 2026 call for input asks where clearer rules or guidance would help and where the cost of compliance is disproportionate to the risks a firm poses.

Questions about how firms assess their financial resources emerged early. In 2023, the FCA found that some investment firms had prepared plans for winding down their own business without considering whether the same event could also force their parent or a sister company to close. (see IFPR implementation observations)) A subsidiary relying on group funding could therefore overestimate the cash available when it needed to pay staff, settle obligations and return client assets. The FCA is now asking whether its guidance gives firms enough direction on planning for a wind-down across an interconnected group.

The FCA’s November 2025 data-quality review exposed a different problem. Supervisors compared the figures firms submitted in their annual prudential return with the internal assessment their boards had approved. They also checked calculations across returns. For some firms, measures such as the value of daily trading activity feed into the calculation of minimum capital requirements. Supervisors could take the activity figures from one return and recalculate the capital requirement reported in another. Of the requirements they checked this way, 85% matched. An unexplained difference leaves supervisors with a question when deciding which firms may need closer attention: how much confidence can they place in the reported capital figures?

The immediate decision for the FCA is which parts of the regime to change. By 20 January 2027, it’s evidence of where the rules work well, where firms duplicate effort and where requirements could better reflect the risks of different businesses. It will consider submissions alongside discussions with firms and trade associations before consulting on proposed changes later in 2027.

Reconciling the Capital Figure

For teams preparing capital adequacy returns, the FCA has identified a specific calculation worth revisiting. A firm compares its permanent regulatory minimum with two estimates: the capital it needs to stay in business and the capital it needs to wind down. Each estimate has its own regulatory floor. The highest of the three figures determines the threshold. A reporting team can reproduce that calculation before filing and trace the estimate that determined the result back to the assessment the board approved.

If the figures differ, the question is what happened between approval and submission. Examples include a change in the business, or a figure entered in pounds-gross where the return calls for thousands. Recording the source, reporting date and reason for each material adjustment gives finance and risk teams a way to resolve the difference. It also gives firms evidence for their response to the FCA: which errors could clearer reporting instructions prevent, and which can firms catch through their own checks?

In an October 2025 survey by the Personal Investment Management & Financial Advice Association (PIMFA), 48% of the 52 member firms surveyed identified simpler reporting and fewer duplicate returns as a priority. For capital reporting teams responding to the current review, a concrete example would be two returns that require staff to prepare the same underlying figure twice, together with an estimate of the work that a common definition would save.

Discrepancies in capital reporting are not limited to the UK. In its 2026 report on broker-dealer audit inspections, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB) described an auditor who missed an error when reconciling the net capital calculation accompanying a broker-dealer’s financial statements with the figure in its regulatory filing. In the EU, data quality limited what supervisors themselves could assess. Of 275 investment firms in a 2025 EBA and ESMA sample, 191 supplied data of sufficient quality for an analysis of on- and off-balance-sheet items.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Generative and Agentic AI in Financial Markets: What the Data Really Shows

Artificial intelligence is reshaping financial markets – but the reality on the ground is more nuanced, more uneven, and more instructive than the headlines suggest. A new A-Team Insight research programme, drawing on responses from senior AI decision-makers at buy-side and sell-side institutions across the USA, UK and Canada, reveals a market in transition: from...

BLOG

FCA Opens Consultation on New Transaction Reporting Regime

The Financial Conduct Authority’s latest transaction reporting consultation sets out how firms would apply rules that change reporting responsibilities, client data exchanges and the treatment of historical records. Preparing for the April 2028 deadline will require decisions about who supplies reporting data and how systems preserve it through the transition. Published in August 2026, Policy...

EVENT

AI in Capital Markets Summit London

Now in its 3rd year, the AI in Capital Markets Summit returns with a focus on the practicalities of onboarding AI enterprise wide for business value creation. Whilst AI offers huge potential to revolutionise capital markets operations many are struggling to move beyond pilot phase to generate substantial value from AI.

GUIDE

AI in Capital Markets Handbook 2026

AI adoption in capital markets has moved into a more disciplined phase. The priority is now controlled deployment: where AI can be used safely, where it can deliver measurable value, and how outputs can be governed, monitored and evidenced. The 2026 edition of the AI in Capital Markets Handbook examines how AI is being applied...