The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

FCA Chief: Shaking Up the Regulatory Rule Book Post-Brexit

Subscribe to our newsletter

Andrew Bailey, the CEO of the UK’s Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), this week laid out his thoughts on the future of financial conduct regulation – outlining a series of bold statements regarding the importance of risk-taking and competition, the benefits of a minimum regulation environment, and the challenges of equivalence with the EU that could see the UK move in a very different direction post-Brexit.

Almost uniquely among financial regulators, the FCA has a specific objective to promote competition in the interests of consumers, and Bailey emphasised the centrality of this to the FCA approach – a point that should reassure institutions apprehensive about the ever-increasing regulatory burden. “Advancing the public interest does not mean that we have no interest in corporate health and profitability. Healthy competition depends on firms earning returns on the investment made. And, in fact, our governing legislation already tells us that we should take into account the desirability of sustainable economic growth in the UK.”

The UK will continue to be an active member of ESMA and work closely with its EU27 counterparts on legislation that is already in development while the UK negotiates its departure – and Bailey stressed that the relationship would remain close. However, he also highlighted the differences between the UK and EU approach to regulation – suggesting that the UK could make a radical break from previous tradition and move towards a potentially less invasive approach to oversight.

Over the years, the EU has moved from a system which sets minimum standards of regulation (the world of minimum harmonised directives) to one filled with standards that are both minimum and maximum (the world of maximum harmonised regulation and directives) – a change which Bailey acknowledged could be “intrusive at the national level,” although it has undeniably played a valuable role in ensuring a level playing field and facilitating supervisory cooperation across the EU market.

However: “Left to our own devices, I think the UK regulatory system would evolve somewhat differently,” he confirmed. This would be likely to incorporate a more principles-based approach, taking on board practical experience and focusing less on detailed rules and regulations, which can drive fragmentation in markets.

“I see rules as a means to deliver outcomes, and it is important not to focus too much on rules as the beginning and end of the process of regulation,” he said. “Outcomes matter at the end of the day… rules are a means to deliver them, but not the only one.”

Based on Bailey’s comments, it looks as if the UK post-Brexit could move in a rather different direction – towards a financial system that focuses on sustainable and transparent returns based on fair and regulated risk, without undue oversight or excessive box-ticking. “There should be a debate about the future of regulation,” concluded Bailey. This debate, assuming it includes the opinions of affected institutions and stakeholders, has the potential to provide much-needed relief for institutions already struggling under an immense regulatory burden.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: The evolution of market surveillance across sell-side and buy-side firms

Market surveillance is crucial, and in many cases a regulatory requirement, to ensuring orderly securities markets and sustaining confidence in trading. It can be breached and has become increasingly complex in the wake of the Covid pandemic, Brexit, and the emergence of new asset classes. This webinar will review the extent of market abuse in...

BLOG

Deutsche Bank Indonesia Teams with Xceptor to Automate Tax Processes for Post-Trade Settlement

Deutsche Bank Corporate Bank has adopted an automated workflow platform for the administration of capital gains withholding tax during the post-trade settlement process in Indonesia. The platform, based on the Xceptor Tax Solution, is aimed at streamlining manual processes and reducing the time to calculate withholding tax amounts down to seconds. Deutsche Bank will also...

EVENT

Data Management Summit New York

Now in its 12th year, the Data Management Summit (DMS) in NYC brings together the North American, capital markets enterprise data management community, to explore the evolution of data strategy and how to leverage data to drive compliance and business insight.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2021/2022 – Ninth Edition

Welcome to the ninth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook, a publication dedicated to helping you gain a full understanding of regulations related to your organisation from the details of requirements to best practice implementation. This edition of the handbook includes a focus on regulations being rolled out to bring order and standardisation to...