About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

CCP Principles Can be Applied to Bilateral World of OTC Derivatives, Says Adsatis

Subscribe to our newsletter

Following on from its white paper last month, London-based consultancy Adsatis has published another report looking into the clearing counterparty (CCP) approach in comparison to bilateral agreements with regards to OTC derivatives. Adsatis consultant and author of the white paper, Bill Hodgson, reckons firms can apply aspects of the CCP approach to a non-CCP environment.

“Commentators, politicians and regulators have variously suggested hugely complex solutions to the worlds credit exposure crisis, such as a global trade registration system, clearing every single OTC product through a massive CCP, or abolishing OTC products altogether. Our contention is that the framework is already in place to handle the measurement and mitigation processes, but perhaps the market could learn from the CCP approach in how protection layers are constructed,” explains Hodgson.

The white paper, entitled “Comparing the ISDA bilateral exposure management model with a CCP”, like the title suggests, compares the way credit risk is managed using the bilateral ISDA Credit Support Annex (CSA) versus the risk management approach of a CCP. It highlights areas of difference such as membership criteria, quality of protection from credit risk and operational and timing issues.

Hodgson suggests that it may now be time for “CSA 2.0” in order to provide a more “meaningful link between risk and protection” in light of the current financial climate. Principles such as agreed data formats for publishing reconciliation data and the publication of the date on which the last valuation was calculated for a trade, both of which are used in the CCP version, could be adopted in the new version of the CSA, suggests the paper.

Although many OTC products will never be suitable for a CCP, this does not mean CCP principles cannot be applied to the area, Hodgson suggests. He concludes: “Isn’t it time to blend the experience of both markets and upgrade the financial technology to give firms a higher level of protection and a positive feedback loop to associate higher margin levels with illiquid products and to balance banks enthusiasm for such risky trading?”

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: The Data Office at a Crossroads — AI Governance, Organisational Design, and the Evolving Mandate of the CDO

Who owns AI governance in a capital markets firm – and is the Data Office structured to bear that weight? These questions sit at the heart of A-Team Research’s latest findings, presented here for the first time: the combined results of two landmark surveys examining the role of the Data Office in AI governance and...

BLOG

Adapting to an AI-Dominated World: Data Management Summit New York City Review

The 16th Data Management Summit New York City immersed delegates in a deep dive into the implications of artificial intelligence and associated agents as the technologies dominate discussions among data chiefs of the world’s financial institutions. In the opening Data Leaders Panel, The Evolving Data And Ai Operating Model – Synergy, Governance And Accountability, the...

EVENT

TradingTech Summit London

Now in its 16th year, the TradingTech Summit London brings together senior leadership across capital markets trading technology and market data. Join us to deep dive into key opportunities and challenges driving technological transformation across sell-side and buy-side firms.

GUIDE

The DORA Implementation Playbook: A Practitioner’s Guide to Demonstrating Resilience Beyond the Deadline

The Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) has fundamentally reshaped the European Union’s financial regulatory landscape, with its full application beginning on January 17, 2025. This regulation goes beyond traditional risk management, explicitly acknowledging that digital incidents can threaten the stability of the entire financial system. As the deadline has passed, the focus is now shifting...