About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Concern Remains as Delay, Revision and Data Hang Over FRTB

Subscribe to our newsletter

The proposed Fundamental Review of the Trading Book (FRTB) was formulated to protect banks against a repeat of the devastation caused to the sector during the 2008 financial crisis.

Initially suggested in 2012, it was drawn up in 2016 by the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS), and revised in 2019 with a view to implementation soon after.

However, as well as undergoing revision, FRTB’s implementation has also been delayed by the pandemic. Consequently banks around the world are in various states of preparedness – a situation that observers suggest pose potential problems in its final implementation and impact.

How the regulation is applied internationally will be among the many topics discussed at A-Team’s Data Management Insight’s next webinar “FRTB: What Still Needs to be Done Before the Global Deadline of January 2023?”

The event will gather senior industry leaders to discuss FRTB’s next steps, including Marco Crotti, Policy Expert, European Banking Authority; Hany Farag, Senior Director, Head of Methodology and Analytics, Capital Markets Risk Management, CIBC; Santosh Erukulla, Regulatory Reporting Oversight, Handelsbanken Plc; and, Fausto Marseglia, Head of Product Management, FRTB and Regulatory, Refinitiv, an LSEG business.

“We are almost approaching the end of the journey, and yet, not all solutions are polished and ready,” says CIBC’s Farag ahead of the March 8 webinar.

Capital Firewall

FRTB seeks to draw a line between banks’ trading activities and their lending and deposits business. The reckoning is that crises could be prevented from spreading from the trading business to the to banking activities if there are sufficient firewalls in the shape of capital buffers.

FRTB seeks to create those protections by raising the bar on how much capital banks must provide to absorb shocks. That’s meant banks have had to put a lot of work into being FRTB-ready. Among one of the biggest challenges has been data.

“There is a big data management issue, which clearly is bringing complexity and clearly is requiring a lot of investment,” Refinitiv’s Marseglia tells Data Management Insight.

FRTB has imposed tougher requirements for banks that want to calculate their own capital requirements instead of using a standardised approach set by the BCBS.

The internal model approach (IMA) would give banks the benefit of putting less capital aside, as long as they can pass stringent tests of their financial health. To do so demands the gathering of far more internal trade data than banks have done before – or are even capable of collecting.

“For the first time, banks that implement internal models will have to source trade data,” Marseglia adds. “This is a challenge because the systems they have may not have been designed for adding a consistent data management architecture for easily extracting that information.

“And more importantly, they will have to buy data from external vendors. They will have to implement processes for taking the data, sourcing the data and commingling the data with their internal data.”

Tough Approval

Securing external data also would require obtaining a tough set of approvals to ensure the vendors are compliant with the regulation.

Farag argues that getting their data strategies right must be the priority of banks from now on.

“A lot of banks today out there on the standardised approach may not be (suitably) set up so there is a fairly heavy build for them,” he says. The new complexities added to calculating capital according to the IMA will “come with their own data complexities”.

The process of becoming FRTB-ready has progressed at variable speeds, creating an uneven pattern of preparation among banks across – and even within – jurisdictions.

Generally, say observers, the larger banks are further along the road to compliance, mostly because they have the resources to invest in the necessary changes. Banks in developed economies generally also are more prepared.

Europe and Asian jurisdictions, especially Hong Kong, are considered ahead of the UK and US in terms of implementation. And that, by and large, is reflected in the readiness of their banks.

However, the picture is more nuanced.

In the US, for instance, where authorities aren’t expected to take action until 2024, there’s even the suggestion that some banks have taken the delay as a signal to linger. One senior banking observer even suggests some American lenders may have lost interest in getting their processes ready.

Renewed Focus

Such disparities raise concern that an uneven playing field of compliance will result. European banks that have “steamed” ahead, as one observer describes the situation, may find itself at a disadvantage if it has put in place controls required under FRTB that other banks have not.

“They will have to allocate more capital, more money than they were before and this will put them, in a business perspective, at a disadvantage because they will have less money for investments,” explains Marseglia.

Farag agrees, saying that regulators should renew their focus on FRTB.

“What is not desirable is that not all jurisdictions have declared their timelines, and they’re not all alone,” he says. “It would be a lot better if all the jurisdictions aligned as a way of following these principles.”

Farag tempers his concern, however. The delay has given banks and jurisdictional regulators more time to get themselves ready, he argues. And while some are procrastinating  – and even hoping FRTB will be diluted or abandoned – they have largely used the time well.

“Obviously it’s a non-trivial preparation; it does cost to implement the rules in a way that ensures success; and, there are very high hurdles in terms of performance,” he says. “But we view it as a positive outcome. I think overall, the regulators have really shown a very productive dialogue and I think they’ve done a good job responding to the industry debates that we have.”

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Mastering Data Lineage for Risk, Compliance, and AI Governance

Financial institutions are under increasing pressure to ensure data transparency, regulatory compliance, and AI governance. Yet many struggle with fragmented data landscapes, poor lineage tracking and compliance gaps. This webinar will explore how enterprise-grade data lineage can help capital markets participants ensure regulatory compliance with obligations such as BCBS 239, CCAR, IFRS 9, SEC requirements...

BLOG

Data Concern Over EU’s Streamlining of Green Regulations

Financial institutions may have to rely more heavily on their data teams and vendors to surface sustainability risks in their portfolios after the European Union watered down some of its key corporate ESG reporting regulations. The EU’s Omnibus package announced earlier this year is intended to streamline the compliance processes for regulations including the Corporate...

EVENT

AI in Capital Markets Summit New York

The AI in Capital Markets Summit will explore current and emerging trends in AI, the potential of Generative AI and LLMs and how AI can be applied for efficiencies and business value across a number of use cases, in the front and back office of financial institutions. The agenda will explore the risks and challenges of adopting AI and the foundational technologies and data management capabilities that underpin successful deployment.

GUIDE

The DORA Implementation Playbook: A Practitioner’s Guide to Demonstrating Resilience Beyond the Deadline

The Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA) has fundamentally reshaped the European Union’s financial regulatory landscape, with its full application beginning on January 17, 2025. This regulation goes beyond traditional risk management, explicitly acknowledging that digital incidents can threaten the stability of the entire financial system. As the deadline has passed, the focus is now shifting...