The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Opinion: Data Management – Still Not Available in High Definition

By Steve Young, CEO, Citisoft

“The shepherd drives the wolf from the sheep, for which the sheep thanks the shepherd as his liberator, while the wolf denounces him for the same act as the destroyer of liberty. Plainly, the sheep and the wolf are not agreed upon a definition of liberty. ”

– Abraham Lincoln

What defines a market? The structure of a well-functioning market is defined by the theory of perfect competition, but as we all know, well-functioning markets in the real world are never perfect. Nevertheless, some basic structural characteristics are clear: many small buyers and sellers; buyers and sellers have equal access to information; and products are comparable. In simple terms, a defined market should have defined solutions to that market’s needs, and a healthy mix of vendors to provide those solutions.

In the case of data management in the UK, there are one or two vendors that absolutely dominate the market, there is very little true competition and the products are for the most part incomparable. And as is the case with so many areas of investment management technology, in data management it is predominantly product flexibility and very effective marketing as opposed to truly innovative software that have accounted for large slices of market share. The most successful products on the market are the most adaptable and can address multiple problems.

As a consequence, many of the ‘data management solutions’ that have been deployed by investment managers are in fact tactical systems that address one functional problem, as opposed to a genuine strategic solution that addresses an enterprise-wide issue.

Indeed, many vendors have moved into the data management ‘market’ through the development of a tactical system that serves a need in middle-office functions such as performance or reporting. In these instances, the data management element of the system is often little more than fairly basic data extraction, cleansing or aggregation. As a result, almost any vendor can claim to provide some form of data management within their software. The problem is that it is very easy to claim that you can provide a service in a market that has become almost impossible to define. This confusion obviously benefits the vendors more than the asset management clients.

And this is the crux of the problem. Across the investment management industry, there is no single agreed definition of what the term ‘data management’ actually refers to. It means many things to many people, depending on for example whether they are in the front, middle or back office; head of IT, a client relationship manager or head of an equities desk; or employed by a custodian or a small wealth manager and so on. To some people it refers to reference data, while to others it means market data, client data, performance data, compliance-related data, structured and unstructured data or a myriad of other alternatives. My view is that ‘data management market’ is a generic term for a lot of different markets – not merely market sectors that benefit from clear demarcation in the eyes of the buyer.

The confusion around data management even extends beyond our own industry. ‘Big Data’ is a good example, where the term means one thing in investment management circles but something very different in other industries such as online retailing or Internet dating, where unstructured data has a significant role.

Within investment management circles, data management needs to be more focused on who are the manufacturers of the data, who are the consumers and an examination of the data usage within the organisation at a holistic level. In this way it will shift from being predominantly a tactical issue to one that strikes at the very heart of investment operations.

In the future perhaps the industry will move away from using the term ‘data management ‘toward words or descriptors that are much more specific. And I will have to think of more inventive titles for my blog….

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: The Global LEI System – A Solution for Entity Data?

This webinar has passed, but you can view the recording here. As 2013 comes to a close, the global legal entity identifier system – or GLEIS – will have been in the making for 18 months. This year has seen some significant developments ranging from the first meeting of the Regulatory Oversight Committee to a...

BLOG

A-Team Group Names Winners of Data Management Insight Awards 2020

A-Team Group has announced the winners of its prestigious Data Management Insight Awards 2020. The annual awards, now in their eighth year, recognise leading providers of data management solutions, services and consultancy to capital markets participants. The award winners were announced online across categories ranging from best sell-side and buy-side data management platforms to best...

EVENT

Data Management Summit Virtual

The Data Management Summit Virtual brings together the global data management community to share lessons learned, best practice guidance and latest innovations to emerge from the recent crisis. Hear from leading data practitioners and innovators from the UK, US and Europe who will share insights into how they are pushing the boundaries with data to deliver value with flexible but resilient data driven strategies.

GUIDE

Fatca – Getting to Grips with the Challenge Ahead

The industry breathed a sigh of relief when the deadline for reporting under the US Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (Fatca) was pushed back to July 1, 2014. But what’s starting to look like perhaps the most significant regulation of the next 12 months may start to impact our marketplace sooner than we think, especially...