The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Myners’ Voting Rights Proposals Could Pose Significant Data Challenges

The UK’s Financial Services Secretary Paul Myners’ proposals to establish a two tier shareholder register could add another layer of data complexity for financial institutions operating in the market. The proposals are aimed at ensuring longstanding institutional investors receive greater voting clout than short term investors and preventing the increase in what Myners calls “ownerless corporations”.

Myners this week elaborated on the rationale behind differential voting rights thusly: “We need to look at ways in which we can offer a carrot to some financial institutions to take the issue of ownership more seriously. In many cases hedge funds might only be shareholders for a few weeks. Should they be treated in the same way as a long term shareholder or should we be doing more to reward and engage the long term shareholder?”

The impact of introducing a two tier system, similar to that of France or Sweden, would be to fundamentally alter the current ‘one share, one vote’ principle for shareholders in the UK. This in turn, would significantly impact the way that corporate actions data is weighted and processed, as if any more complexity was needed in this particularly tricky area of the market!

As well as recording when shareholders vote, third party data providers and custodians would be required to weight these votes subject to the different classes of investor. Myners has not yet elaborated on what a long term investor would look like – how long is long term? Industry standard classifications would therefore need to be defined first for these categories, before any of this work could begin.

Obviously data providers and vendors active in markets with multi-tiered voting rights would be at an advantage over those focused solely on markets such as the UK. But it would likely pose a data challenge for custodians’ internal data departments: to add another data attribute to monitor on top of those that already need to be captured in the corporate actions process.

However, the proposals may not get very far, as they have provoked a significant backlash from the institutional investment market, which is wary of a two tier system. David Paterson, head of corporate governance at the National Association of Pension Funds (NAPF), says: “It fails to take into account the need for managers to buy or sell shares based on external factors. What is needed is better dialogue between companies and shareholders.”

The Investment Management Association is also up in arms about the idea and contends that the government should not be in a position to mandate the best way for firms to manage money. Multi-tiered voting rights would potentially expose firms to be subject to the whim of a small group of investors, the industry group argues.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: A new way of collaborating with data

Digital transformation in the financial services sector has raised many questions around data, including the cost and volume of reference data required by each financial institution. Firms want to pick and choose the reference data they need to fulfil their requirements. Emerging solutions with the potential to decrease the cost of data and increase flexibility...

BLOG

Opensee Platform Provides Self-Service Big Data Analytics for Business Users

Paris-based ICA, a provider of big data analytics, has rebranded as Opensee, marking its evolution from an innovative capital markets data analytics platform to a market challenger. The company’s offer is to make hundreds of terabytes of structured data accessible to business users easily and quickly through self-service data analytics tools. The company was initially...

EVENT

Data Management Summit USA Virtual

Now in its 11th year, the Data Management Summit USA Virtual explores the shift to the new world where data is redefining the operating model and firms are seeking to unlock value via data transformation projects for enterprise gain and competitive edge.

GUIDE

What the Global Legal Entity Identifier (LEI) Will Mean for Your Firm

It’s hard to believe that as early as the 2009 Group of 20 summit in Pittsburgh the industry had recognised the need for greater transparency as part of a wider package of reforms aimed at mitigating the systemic risk posed by the OTC derivatives market. That realisation ultimately led to the Dodd Frank Act, and...