The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

IMA Highlights Danger of Systemic Risk Data Overload in AIFMD Response

In its response to the European Securities and Markets Authority’s (ESMA) consultation on the Alternative Investment Fund Management Directive (AIFMD), the UK’s Investment Management Association (IMA) highlights the danger of overloading regulators with too much data for the purposes of systemic risk monitoring. IMA director Julie Patterson indicates that under the directive as it currently stands, regulators risk being buried under mountains of “superfluous data, which could lead to a build up of system risk being overlooked.”

Patterson says that rather than asking for such a wide ranging list of data items from firms in their reporting under AIFMD, ESMA should instead consider that “it is important that information is focused so we can readily identify and monitor potential causes of systemic risk.” Asking for the right data items is therefore key to this endeavour.

The IMA response to this particular buy side focused piece of regulation therefore has some similarities to the criticisms levelled at the Office of Financial Research (OFR) and the Dodd Frank Act by the International Securities Market Advisory Group (ISMAG) and Stephen Daffron, Morgan Stanley’s global head of operations, technology and data. Daffron spoke out about the subject during Sifma’s Operations and Technology Committee meeting in May and noted that the current state of the financial services industry’s raw data is not conducive to being fed into an analytics engine in order to track granular data such as parent/child hierarchies. He indicated three main points of concern: the sheer volume of unstructured data out there; the lack of consistency (of data itself and the OFR’s approach to that data); and the OFR’s intended approach to the challenge overall.

Back in September last year, John Gubert, chairman of ISMAG also noted that regulators would have difficulty sifting through and making sense of the data they are asking firms to provide for risk monitoring purposes. Indeed, he warned that it could result in death by data drowning.

Author and epistemologist Nassim Nicholas Taleb took the argument much further back in July, during a government organised conference on the subject of the OFR . Taleb, who is most famous for his book on unpredictability The Black Swan, suggested that relying on what he calls “sterile data” to monitor systemic risk could engender a false sense of security and is not therefore a worthwhile endeavour at which to throw government money.

Although Taleb’s comments are on the extreme side, serious concerns have therefore been raised about the capacity of the US OFR and other regulators to be able to effectively process and number crunch the high volumes of reference and economic data that they will receive from the industry in order to monitor systemic risk.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Getting ready for Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and ESG – what action should asset managers be taking now?

Interest in Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) investment has exploded in recent years, bringing with it regulation and a requirement for buy-side firms to develop ESG strategies and meet disclosure obligations. The sell-side can help here by integrating ESG data with traditional financial information, although the compliance burden remains with asset managers. The EU Sustainable...

BLOG

SteelEye Targets Buy Side with Three-Tiered Surveillance Suite

SteelEye has launched a three-tier suite of communications compliance capabilities aimed at addressing the regulatory obligations of any size of financial institution. SteelEye is hoping this flexibility of approach makes its record-keeping and surveillance platform more appealing to smaller buy-side players that often lack the budget or resource capability to implement extensive platform solutions. SteelEye’s...

EVENT

Data Management Summit New York City (Redirected)

Now in its 8th year, the Data Management Summit (DMS) in NYC explores the shift to the new world where data is redefining the operating model and firms are seeking to unlock value via data transformation projects for enterprise gain and competitive edge.

GUIDE

ESG Handbook 2021

A-Team Group’s ESG Handbook 2021 is a ‘must read’ for all capital markets participants, data vendors and solutions providers involved in Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) investing and product development. It includes extensive coverage of all elements of ESG, from an initial definition and why ESG is important, to existing and emerging regulations, data challenges...