The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

CFTC’s Dunn Admits That Key Market Definitions are Missing from Reforms at the Outset

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has spent most of the start of this year complaining about its dire situation with regards to funding, but this week saw definitive proof that the regulatory reform process is starting off down the wrong track, with the admission by CFTC commissioner Michael Dunn that the regulator is pushing ahead without first putting in place vital market definitions. Confirming the fears voiced by industry participants including Sifma’s resident and CEO Tim Ryan earlier this year, Dunn indicated that tight timelines are forcing the regulator to go ahead with reforms without first laying down the groundwork and agreeing and establishing the necessary industry definitions and standards.

“We’re trying to get things out, but we really don’t have the right nomenclature out there,” Dunn told attendees to Commodity Markets Council conference earlier this week. He elaborated on the pressure the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) are facing to get reforms enacted quickly before the July deadline passes and before funding runs out.

He also noted that working alongside the SEC has proved challenging because of the need to work together to draw up new standards for the OTC markets, rather than acting alone. The old adage that two heads are better than one does not apply when disagreements break out and there isn’t time to resolve them. Dunn’s reference to “turf” issues breaking out is not surprising, given both regulators’ history in the OTC markets.

Dunn’s honesty about the matter is likely to be linked to the fact he’s set to leave the regulator in June, although a replacement has not yet been named. It is also indicative of the serious challenge the industry may face if the regulatory community fails to establish the required data details before it rushes ahead with reforms. Firstly, how can the industry expect to provide feedback to proposals when the basic definitions are not in place to be able to judge these proposals? “It’s hard for you to comment on what we have out there, when you don’t know what we’re talking about,” Dunn admitted.

This is also worrying when you consider the feedback that the Office of Financial Research has recently received regarding its legal entity identification proposals, which are also tied to a July deadline. The vast majority of respondents have asked for further clarity about the fundamentals of the proposals, including which entities will be covered and key terms used within the documentation itself). If items such as this are not addressed, firms will be unable to act on the new requirements and the reforms will be full of (loop)holes.

Last month, Sifma’s Ryan warned of the dangers of regulators pushing ahead regardless of the consequences. “It’s more important that you get it right than you get it done on a deadline that is relatively abstract,” he warned the regulatory community. It looks like this advice has been disregarded.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Getting ready for Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and ESG – what action should asset managers be taking now?

Interest in Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) investment has exploded in recent years, bringing with it regulation and a requirement for buy-side firms to develop ESG strategies and meet disclosure obligations. The sell-side can help here by integrating ESG data with traditional financial information, although the compliance burden remains with asset managers. The EU Sustainable...

BLOG

Advancing Regulatory Data Collections Systems

By Ken Lamar, Founder and Principal Partner, Lamar Associates LLC (With Robert Lee, Executive Director, North America Client Engagement, AxiomSL). Regulators are beginning a journey to design the next generation of data collection systems. A critical aspect of the design process is the need for new data capabilities to effectively conduct supervisory activities to ensure...

EVENT

ESG Regulation, Reporting & Data Management Summit (Redirected)

This summit will explore challenges around assembling and evaluating ESG data for reporting and the impact of regulatory measures and industry collaboration on transparency and standardisation efforts. Expert speakers will address how the evolving market infrastructure is developing and the role of new technologies and alternative data in improving insight and filling data gaps.

GUIDE

Trading Regulations Handbook 2021

In these unprecedented times, a carefully crafted trading infrastructure is crucial for capital markets participants. Yet, the impact of trading regulations on infrastructure can be difficult to manage. The Trading Regulations Handbook 2021 can help. It provides all the essentials you need to know about regulations impacting trading operations, data and technology. A-Team Group’s Trading...