About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

The Challenges in ESG Reporting Frameworks, According to Experts

Subscribe to our newsletter

Financial institutions face a mountain of challenges in formulating an ESG reporting framework as they strive to put in place processes to meet a growing body of regulatory obligations.

A lack of disclosed data from investee companies, the multitude of vendors needed to source enough relevant information, the lack of a standardised global reporting framework and poor data quality are among the chief obstacles, a panel of experts told the A-Team Group’s inaugural ESG Data and Tech Summit London.

The growing burden of reporting obligations piled on multinational financial companies was one that Global Legal Entity Identifier Foundation (GLEIF)’s Hany Choueri said was of particular concern, especially as jurisdictions worldwide get to grips with their own rules, creating a patchwork quilt of regulations worldwide.

With firms often required to offer instrument-level information on their holdings, international banks and institutions would be expected to make hundreds of separate submissions, Choueri told speakers on the panel, entitled “How to Develop a Reporting Framework for ESG Disclosure Regulation”.

That could be worsened if each jurisdiction demanded different data and if regulations were formulated and enacted slowly, said Choueri, who is Board Member for Sustainability and Vice Chair at GLEIF.

Data Misconceptions

The data and scores behind ESG disclosures have often been criticised for being subjective or established according to contradictory methodologies. But Chris Johnson, Senior Product Manager, Market Data at HSBC argued that such criticism missed the point. Too many market participants wrongly assumed that ESG data could be treated the same as credit and other data, Johnson said.

Firms needed to spend time properly analysing sustainability information, he said, suggesting that it would be difficult to find data that was purely objective.

Johnson also warned that the slow rollout of regulations in Europe could expose firms to censure. The Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) depends on data presented under the Corporate Sustainable Reporting Directive (CSRD), but the latter isn’t expected to come into force until much later than the former, he warned.

In the absence of a global set of reporting standards, individual financial firms are likely to create their own frameworks, said Vishal Shah, Solutions Specialist at data provider Alveo. He said many companies are pulling together tailored solutions based on a variety of reporting standards in the market, meaning firms would have to deal with a multitude of client approaches in their disclosures, a point of potential problems.

Even once a firm has established what data it needs and had found suitable sources, there still remained the question of whether its technology architecture was able to ingest and manage the content, offered Tim Fox, Product & Regulatory Lead at ESGi. To circumvent a host of associated challenges, Fox suggested a four-step process of researching, identifying, applying and sourcing data before putting in place an ESG strategy.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: MiFID II: Data for transaction reporting

Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II) is complemented by Markets in Financial Instruments Regulation (MiFIR), which builds out transaction reporting requirements with a number of new reporting obligations. The data and data management challenges of reporting include an increase in instruments that must be reported and the addition of several new fields to...

BLOG

Data Concern Over EU’s Streamlining of Green Regulations

Financial institutions may have to rely more heavily on their data teams and vendors to surface sustainability risks in their portfolios after the European Union watered down some of its key corporate ESG reporting regulations. The EU’s Omnibus package announced earlier this year is intended to streamline the compliance processes for regulations including the Corporate...

EVENT

AI in Capital Markets Summit New York

The AI in Capital Markets Summit will explore current and emerging trends in AI, the potential of Generative AI and LLMs and how AI can be applied for efficiencies and business value across a number of use cases, in the front and back office of financial institutions. The agenda will explore the risks and challenges of adopting AI and the foundational technologies and data management capabilities that underpin successful deployment.

GUIDE

Enterprise Data Management, 2010 Edition

The global regulatory community has become increasingly aware of the data management challenge within financial institutions, as it struggles with its own challenge of better tracking systemic risk across financial markets. The US regulator in particular is seemingly keen to kick off a standardisation process and also wants the regulatory community to begin collecting additional...