About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

NYSE Euronext and Eurex Indicate Concern Over Derivatives Regulation, CDS CCP Debate Continues

Subscribe to our newsletter

Two of the contenders in the credit default swap (CDS) clearing counterparty (CCP) race, NYSE Euronext and Eurex, have expressed their concern about a draft bill in the US aimed at expanding derivatives regulation. The firms are worried that the regulation, which would require mandatory clearing of most OTC products, would have the unintended consequence of preventing non-US clearing companies from entering the market.

The bill was proposed and drafted by Agriculture Committee Chairman Collin Peterson and would require all CDS CCPs to be regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). It would also require that the CFTC impose detailed reporting requirements on those CCPs. Peterson is keen to make the market more stable amid complaints that speculators in derivatives markets contributed to commodity price jumps and that a lack of oversight amplified the credit crisis.

To express their concern, the chief regulatory officer of NYSE Liffe, Karl Cooper, and a member of the executive board for Eurex and Eurex Clearing, Thomas Book, spoke before the House Agriculture Committee this week. “Eurex Clearing currently does not operate in the US, but would like to consider offering clearing and other services here in the future with respect to OTC contracts, agreements and transactions,” said Book.

Thus far, NYSE Euronext is the only CCP contender that has received the necessary approvals from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to offer clearing for CDSs in the US. Cooper is concerned that the restrictive legislation will force it to seek approval from the CFTC as well as the SEC. “The OTC derivatives market is a global market, which demands a global response,” he added.

The Security Industry and Financial Markets Association (Sifma) and the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA) have also sated that the bill would have a negative impact on the CDS market. Robert Pickel, CEO of ISDA, said the draft rule could force firms to terminate privately negotiated contacts and undermine legal certainty of some trades. A Sifma spokesperson called the move “impractical and unnecessary”.

However, the US is not the only jurisdiction in regulatory uproar with regards to the CDS CCP plans, European Commissioner for Internal Market and Services Charlie McCreevy has continued his campaign for a European only CCP this month. He has gone as far as threatening legislation in this area to spur on the industry to action. The European Commission is also considering the regulation of the credit derivatives market in general at the moment with regards to more adequately monitoring risk.

ISDA is strongly against the idea of multiple regional clearing houses and has been championing the establishment of a single CCP for all trades. Eraj Shirvani, the chairman of ISDA and the head of European credit at Credit Suisse, has indicated that the association is keen to establish “global dialogue with all concerned regulators as a matter or priority”.

The US is also continuing the ongoing debate about which body should regulate the derivatives market, the SEC or the CFTC, or whether the two should be merged. Despite calls for a merger, Gary Gensler, US President Barack Obama’s nominee to head the CFTC, is not keen on the idea and hopes to retain control over the regulation of derivatives rather than ceding it to the SEC.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: How to apply innovative e-comms surveillance whilst ensuring control, compliance and enhanced productivity

Remember the days when email was the predominant media for electronic communications within and among financial institutions? Fast forward to today, and email represents a declining fraction of these e-comms, many of which are hosted by modern collaborative platforms such as Microsoft Teams, Webex, Slack, and Zoom, and all of which are subject to surveillance....

BLOG

FINRA Outlines Perspective on RegTech

RegTech innovation is commendable, but must be accompanied by risk mitigation, seen as a means to an end rather than an end in itself, and selected for use by a cross-section of an organisation that is inclusive of, but not limited to, IT and compliance. Opening A-Team Group’s RegTech Summit New York with a keynote...

EVENT

RegTech Summit London

Now in its 6th year, the RegTech Summit in London will bring together the RegTech ecosystem to explore how the European capital markets financial industry can leverage technology to drive innovation, cut costs and support regulatory change.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2022/2023 – Tenth Edition

Welcome to the tenth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook, a publication that has tracked new regulations, amendments, implementation and data management requirements as regulatory change has impacted global capital markets participants over the past 10 years. This edition of the handbook includes new regulations and highlights some of the major regulatory interventions challenging...