About a-team Marketing Services

A-Team Insight Blogs

Latest UK SDR Measure Highlights Data Challenge

Subscribe to our newsletter

The UK has implemented the latest stage of its sustainability disclosure requirement (SDR), which is designed to encourage manufacturers of investment products to adopt measures that will prevent greenwashing.

Before the measure was even introduced by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), however, it was apparent that fund managers’ likelihood of adopting the guidance would be limited by their data setups. Experts have told Data Management Insight that solving this challenge would be critical to meeting the goals that underpin the SDR.

Since July 31, managers have been asked to voluntarily label their products according to the degree to which they can be considered sustainable.

Those labelled “Sustainability Improvers” denote assets that have the potential to become sustainable but may not be now. “Sustainability Impact” products are those that invest in solutions that bring beneficial ESG impacts. “Sustainability Mixed Goals” labels indicate investment vehicles that combine the other two. A fourth, “Sustainability Focus”, is reserved for products that have at least 70% of allocations to sustainable assets.

Those seeking to adopt the labels must show they meet the requirements by the beginning of December.

Clarity Needed

Critics have predicted a slow uptake of the labels by fund houses, with some arguing that more clarity is needed about how the labels can be properly applied. At the heart of that challenge is likely to be firms’ ability to gather and use the data necessary to make those decisions.

The FCA said last year that asset managers and manufacturers must have robust data, governance and technology setups to adopt its measures. A poll during a webinar by consultancy firm Bovill Newgate, however, found that 90% of financial services respondents said they were not equipped with the correct ESG reporting data.

Emil Stigsgaard Fuglsang, co-founder at ESG data and consultancy firm Matter said data would be a potential pain point for firms operating in the UK.

“While many global investment managers already have these competencies in place thanks to the requirements of other regulations, the majority of smaller British firms do not,” Fugslang said.

“This means they face the challenge of accurately defining sustainability in their investments and implementing data and analytics solutions to track and document their performance against these definitions at the fund-level. This will be no easy task, but those who take action now will be best prepared by the December 2 deadline.”

Investor Protections

The labelling guidance follows the publication of anti-greenwashing advice by the FCA earlier this year, which seeks to protect investors from abuse by encouraging asset managers and manufacturers to be clear and precise in the descriptions of their products.

The FCA is keen to safeguard investors against being lured by false claims of an asset or product’s sustainability. The threat of greenwashing has been wielded as a weapon in an ESG backlash, most notably in the US, that has seen billions of dollars pulled from sustainability-linked funds.

While the measure is designed primarily to protect retail investors, it is expected also to have an impact on institutional capital allocators. One of the first funds to adopt an SDR label, AEW’s impact fund, has taken the Sustainable Impact categorisation and is offered only to institutions.

The SDR is also widely predicted to set transparency standards that institutions are likely to follow.

ESMA Guidance

The UK’s latest SDR implementation came as Europe’s regulators sought changes to some of the European Union’s disclosure rules. The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), last week suggested changes that would affect the bloc’s lynchpin Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) and other measures.

In an opinion piece it set out a set of proposals that urge tweaks to the EU’s wider sustainable finance framework, arguing that there needs to be greater “interconnectedness between its different components”.

Among ESMA’s proposals are a phasing out of the phrase “sustainable investments” within the SFDR and a recommendation that market participants should instead make reference only to the green Taxonomy that underpins European market rules. Further, it suggested an acceleration of the Taxonomy’s completion, incorporating a social taxonomy.

It also urged that ESG data products be brought under regulatory scrutiny to improve their quality.

Clash of Standards

Other recommendations on how sustainability products should be described could conflict with the new measures introduced by the FCA.

ESMA suggests that all products provide basic information on their sustainability, with greatest detail given to institutional investors. It also urges the introduction of a “best in class” product categorisation system. That would include at least a “Sustainability” classification, denoting products that are already green, and a “Transition” grouping of funds that aim to be sustainable.

Martina Macpherson, head of ESG product strategy and management at SIX Financial Information, said institutions would need to familiarise themselves with each code.

“Challenges for asset managers remain to categorise funds in line with the UK’s labelling regime, and to align them with the EU’s fund labelling rules introduced by ESMA,” MacPherson said. “Overall, ESG fund labels represent a significant next step to address transparency and greenwashing concerns. Meanwhile, the mounting public and regulatory attention surrounding sustainable investment demands firms to use the most reliable, legitimate, and timely data to inform their decisions.”

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: The roles of cloud and managed services in optimising enterprise data management

Cloud and managed services go hand-in-hand when it comes to modern enterprise data management (EDM), but how can the best solutions for the business be selected and implemented to ensure optimal data management based on accurate, consistent, and high-quality data, and delivering improved efficiency, better decisions and competitive advantage? This webinar will answer these questions,...

BLOG

AI Startup BlueFlame Raises $5m for Alternative Markets Data Platform

BlueFlame AI, a start-up that harnesses artificial intelligence to help alternative market participants streamline their operational, regulatory and clerical processes, has raised US$5 million in a Series A funding round. The cash injection, which will be used to further develop BlueFlame’s AI platform, raises the company’s value to $50m, the New York- and London-based company...

EVENT

Data Management Summit New York City

Now in its 14th year the Data Management Summit NYC brings together the North American data management community to explore how data strategy is evolving to drive business outcomes and speed to market in changing times.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2024 – Twelfth Edition

Welcome to the twelfth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook, a unique and useful guide to capital markets regulation, regulatory change and the data and data management requirements of compliance. The handbook covers regulation in Europe, the UK, US and Asia-Pacific. This edition of the handbook includes a detailed review of acts, plans and...