About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Culture and Internal Company Set-up Prove Problematic in SMCR Implementation

Subscribe to our newsletter

The Senior Managers Certification Regime (SMCR) is a hot and vexing topic, with internal company set-up and culture presenting a significant challenge for many financial services firms as they prepare for the December 9, 2019 deadline by when arrangements for senior managers and certification staff must be in place for all firms and from when the regulation’s cone of conduct rules will apply. By December 2020, all other staff within the scope of the conduct rules must be trained and compliant.

Webinar Recording: Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR) – challenge or opportunity?

An interactive webinar, which answered many delegate questions about the details of SMCR, was hosted by A-Team Group last week. It set out the requirements of the regulation and compared them to the previous Approved Persons Regime, discussed the regulations scope and considered the penalties of non-compliance and benefits of getting it right. An early poll question, covering the extent to which organisations have implemented SMCR, showed mixed results, with 32% of delegates having implemented the regulation ‘to a certain extent, with quite a lot more to do’, and 30% saying they still had ‘everything to do’. Some 21% said they had implemented ‘to a great extent, with a little more to do’, and 17% ‘to a limited extent, with a lot more to do’.

While many banks and insurers have had to work within an interim regime over the past few years, Dirk Young, SMCR lead at Jupiter Asset Management and a speaker on the webinar, said that while the FCA takes a relatively simplistic view and suggests firms must just evidence what they do, the cultural issues of embedding the regulation across a large organisation can be problematic.

Featured Download: Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR) – challenge or opportunity? poll results

This was borne out in a second delegate poll that revealed 84% of delegates saying the key challenge in implementing SMCR is internal set-up and culture. Duncan Thistleton, governance and conduct consultant in charge of SMCR implementation at Standard Life Aberdeen, said SMCR requires ‘more cultural than implementation change’ and noted that the poll result underlines the very reason why a regime is needed. Senior leadership buy-in and a project team are essential, he added.

Other challenges identified by the poll results included lack of a specific programme and leader, not enough budget, and staff constantly changing jobs. After detailing the requirements of SMCR and its scope, Ashley Kovas, senior regulatory intelligence expert at Thomson Reuters, said tick boxing is no longer sufficient to ensure compliance and that change is needed in the way people understand and behave in their roles. Addressing the challenges of implementation, he noted the need to start early – or, at this stage, as soon as possible, put in place vital policies and procedures, bucket people into one of the four buckets of senior managers, certified staff, code staff and ancillary staff set out in the regulation, and ensure senior managers and staff are familiar with the SMCR code of conduct and understand their accountabilities and responsibilities.

While the regulation has many facets, including the difficulty of keeping on top of job changes, new hires and leavers, careful compliance can offer business benefits. These include better management potentially leading to better business, less chance of issues not being spotted or left to fester for too long, and as Ellen Ogbodo, regulatory consultant on the SMCR programme at Fidelity International, concluded, good and ethical individual and business behaviour.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Upcoming Webinar: Generative and Agentic AI in Financial Markets: What the Data Really Shows

Date: 15 October 2026 Time: 10:00am ET / 3:00pm London / 4:00pm CET Duration: 50 minutes Artificial intelligence is reshaping financial markets – but the reality on the ground is more nuanced, more uneven, and more instructive than the headlines suggest. A new A-Team Insight research programme, drawing on responses from senior AI decision-makers at...

BLOG

Industry Backs FCA AIFM Reform but Warns of Uneven Costs.

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) recently proposed the biggest overhaul of the UK alternative investment fund manager (AIFM) regime since 2013. The projected benefits will depend on whether greater proportionality can reduce compliance overhead without shifting costs to smaller managers. The proposals in CP 26/28 replace the current distinction between full-scope and sub-threshold AIFMs with...

EVENT

Data Management Summit New York City

Now in its 16th year, Data Management Summit (DMS) NYC returns on September 17th 2026, to explore how to use data and AI to drive measurable business outcomes – reliably, repeatedly and at scale.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2026 – Fourteenth Edition

Welcome to the fourteenth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook. Supervisors increasingly expect firms to demonstrate which rules apply, which data supports each obligation, who owns the control and how exceptions are identified and resolved. Policies and implementation programmes must now be supported by records that can withstand regulatory scrutiny. This edition examines material...