About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

CCP for the CDS Market Will Have Very Little Impact on Risk Mitigation, Says Adsatis

Subscribe to our newsletter

Originally appeared in MiFID Monitor

The market may be overestimating the impact that the introduction of a central clearing counterparty (CCP) will have on systemic risk, according to London-based consultancy Adsatis. The firm’s recent white paper, entitled “A central counterparty for OTC credit derivatives – are we over estimating the importance?”, examines the benefits and possible disadvantages of clearing OTC credit derivatives via a CCP.

Bill Hodgson, Adsatis consultant and author of the paper, explains: “The benefits of a CCP for OTC credit products have been widely advertised as reducing ‘systemic’ risk in the capital markets. Our contention is that changing the processing of one high volume product makes no difference to the entire capital markets system, leaving the wider system unaffected. The inability of any CCP to take on the risk mitigation of complex structured credit products, means the CDOs and SIVs at the centre of the current crisis remain untouched by this initiative.”

The white paper examines the characteristics of a CCP and how these will affect industry participants in the CDS market. Hodgson identifies three main benefits to a member of a CCP: the release of credit line usage, the release of regulatory capital and more efficient back office processing.

But he also identifies what he sees as a negative impact: “One downside of having OTC contracts via a CCP is the exclusion of these trades from the existing ISDA based margin agreement between a pair of firms. With a large number of trades being novated to the CCP, this can potentially reduce the effect of exposure netting, and increase the amount of margin required in the bilateral relationship.”

The CCP will also provide benefits to regulators such as a single window into the risk exposures of its members, says Hodgson.

However, he is sceptical that the initiatives will benefit the industry significantly in terms of reducing systemic risk. “If your definition of systemic means the whole capital market, then given the narrow scope of the OTC credit CCP, this benefit doesn’t seem justified given the wide range of other business transacted by the major firms,” he says.

Hodgson puts the introduction of the CCP into this market down to two primary factors: public image that something is being done and the desire of regulators to more closely monitor the sector. He believes the existence of a credit CCP won’t prevent a future crisis and will be a footnote to any history of this period. “If anything this is a tactical step which will be forgotten once launched as we continue to see the after effects of the crisis. And a final note, given the scale of losses in the market so far, can a single CCP absorb such losses bringing concentration of risk into a single entity?”

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Harnessing analytics with trusted and quality data for real-time insight and decision making

Analytics are only as good as the data they analyse, and real-time insight and decision making are only as good as the analytics they are based on, raising questions about how to ensure fundamental data quality and trust in data, data accessibility in real time, and the extent to which this is required in different...

BLOG

Leaders Scrutinise a Changing Industry at A-Team Group’s Annual Data Management Summit New York City

Experts and executives from across the financial data ecosystem gathered at A-Team Group’s Data Management Summit New York 2025 last week to discuss and probe the latest innovations, trends and strategies in our fast-moving industry. From data quality and artificial intelligence agents to modern data architectures and data products, a multitude of current topics were...

EVENT

AI in Data Management Summit New York City

Following the success of the 15th Data Management Summit NYC, A-Team Group are excited to announce our new event: AI in Data Management Summit NYC!

GUIDE

Entity Data Management Handbook – Sixth Edition

High-profile and punitive penalties handed out to large financial institutions for non-compliance with Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know Your Customer (KYC) regulations have catapulted entity data management up the business agenda. So, too, have industry and government reports on the staggering sums of money laundered on a global basis. Less apparent, but equally important, are...