The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

And So it Begins…

Sibos 2010 kicked off this morning to a rather drizzly but promising start; with around 8,000 odd delegates registered for the annual Swift user conference in Amsterdam, it’s set to be a busy week. The securities market infrastructure session began proceedings by debating the benefits of competition versus consolidation in the evolving global market: a topic that is highly relevant for the reference data sector also.

The general consensus of the panellists, which included BNP Paribas’ head of sales and relationship management Alan Cameron and ABN Amro’s CCO Jan Bart de Boer, was that interoperability and competition are preferable to a monopoly in the world of post-trade infrastructures. Interesting news given that this afternoon’s panel on a “golden” securities reference data utility is about setting up such a mandated monopoly.

Rather than imposing a regulatory mandated monopoly, Thomas Zeeb, CEO of SIX Securities Services, argued that interoperability between infrastructures in individual European countries is the more pragmatic and practical option. “However, this level of interoperability needs to be fully supported and this is where regulation is needed: to impose sanctions on those that block interoperability.”

Philip Brown, member of the executive board for Clearstream Banking, added that the cost of establishing a monopoly would potentially make it an unattractive proposition. “If we are aiming to achieve greater efficiency and lower cost across Europe, a single monopoly provider is unlikely to be able to offer this. Moreover, mandating consolidation will not work due to the fact the public sector is not able to agree on something as esoteric as post-trade infrastructure,” he explained.

Cameron agreed and noted that there are significant obstacles in the path of achieving the removal of the Giovannini barriers across Europe, including differences in the treatment of tax and corporate actions from country to country. He pointed to the success of initiatives such as Link-up Markets between central securities depositories (CSDs) as an example of interoperability in action.

He also reiterated the potential cost of a monopoly as a drawback: “It will be difficult to build into a system all the requirements of individual European markets, three or four may be possible, but 20? Who wants to pay for that?”

De Boer reckoned that many local small and mid cap firms would also be uninterested in using a global platform due to cost considerations (an equation that has traditionally put many of these firms off from using Swift, pre-Swift Lite that is). “Local constituents want local silos in order to meet their specific requirements,” he added.

These are arguments that could also be used in the discussions around the establishment of a central reference data utility for Europe. Cost is certainly an issue and the desire for the continuation of domestic standards for data is another that rings true in the reference data context. Perhaps the idea of several commercial providers in the utility context, where data standards mapping is provided, could be a comparable offering to the post-trade infrastructure equation? I await this afternoon’s panel to find out…

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Data Standards – progress and case studies

Global data standards and identifiers are essential to business growth, market stability and cost reduction – but they can be challenging to implement, while a lack of consistency across jurisdictions has presented obstacles to global take-up. However, with regulators starting to sit up and take note, the issue of data standards is coming increasingly to...

BLOG

FactSet Addition of Data-Mapping to Snowflake Links Third-Party, Factset and Proprietary Data in Seconds

FactSet is meeting increasing market demand for rapid content integration, access and control by integrating its data-mapping solution, FactSet Concordance Service, into Snowflake’s cloud data platform. The integration allows investment professionals to quickly link third-party, FactSet, and proprietary content together in the Snowflake platform. The data-mapping solution is scalable and can be used by joint...

EVENT

Data Management Summit Virtual

The Data Management Summit Virtual will bring together the global data management community to share lessons learned, best practice guidance and latest innovations to emerge from the recent crisis. Join us online to hear from leading data practitioners and innovators from the UK, US and Europe who will share insights into how they are pushing the boundaries with data to deliver value with flexible but resilient data driven strategies.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2020/2021 – Eighth Edition

This eighth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook is a ‘must-have’ for capital markets participants during this period of unprecedented change. Available free of charge, it profiles every regulation that impacts capital markets data management practices giving you: A detailed overview of each regulation with key dates, data and data management implications, links to...