The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Post-Trade Data Quality has Deteriorated Since MiFID But Are Current Proposals Enough for Instrument Identification, Asks FISD’s Davin

The market fragmentation that has been a major by-product of the introduction of MiFID has resulted in a number of serious data related issues in the OTC space in particular, said Tom Davin, managing director of the Washington-based Financial Information Services Division (FISD) of the Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA), at the recent MiFID JWG reunion meeting. Regulators are therefore tackling the post-trade space by attempting to introduce a new focus on data quality and timeliness, but the current set of proposed data standards for instrument identification may not be sufficient, suggested Davin.

The focus of the regulatory gaze should rightly be on the OTC space with regards to data quality rather than the regulated venues, said Davin. However, he has some reservations about the regulators’ suggested method of identification for individual securities. The focus on making ISO standards mandatory and using an instrument’s ISIN, currency and trading venue data for individual identification may not be enough, he warned.

“FISD is supportive of the introduction of unique identifiers in order to be able to deal with trade cancellations and corrections but there may be limitations to these metrics,” said Davin. He asked attendees to the meeting to consider any other metrics that could be used for these purposes and feed them back to industry associations and the regulators themselves.

Davin also discussed the challenges inherent in the attempt to consolidate European market data into a consolidated tape. “Data consolidation already happens in this respect at a firm or vendor level, but the idea of establishing a consolidated tape across the industry needs to be carefully considered,” he said.

The Committee of European Securities Regulators (CESR) has two options with regards to establishing such a source for consolidated trade data. It could create approved publishing arrangements and certify some of the vendor third parties in the market to publish data to the market. CESR would then need to maintain a list of these approved vendors. “It would also have to set certain standards for data quality and consistency and it would have to ensure that each trade is only published once if it goes down this route,” explained Davin.

The cost and competitive implications of such a move should also be considered, as the move would likely require the publication of some level of free data. Davin noted that it would also split pre and post-trade data to some extent, but that the industry is seemingly more receptive to the idea of approved publishing arrangements than before.

Alternatively, Europe could see the development of a US style consolidated tape that would aim to be run at cost. However, Davin is concerned that there are a number of unanswered questions around who would run the facility, how it would operate and how much it would cost to set up. “It may be premature to introduce a consolidated tape and the US market experience should be carefully examined in this respect. The latency issues and operational constraints of the US version should be explored. We need to be sure that we need it before we introduce it,” he warned.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Adverse media screening – how to cut exposure to criminal activity, from money laundering to human trafficking

Screening for adverse media coverage of counterparties presents an incredible opportunity for financial institutions to limit risk exposures and identify bad actors early. It is required by regulations such as the EU’s sixth Anti-Money Laundering Directive (AML 6), and is one of the most effective ways to steer clear of potential connections with sanctioned activity...

BLOG

Don’t Miss It – A-Team Group’s Data Management Summit USA Virtual is Just Weeks Away

Data monetisation, data strategy to drive business outcomes, data discovery and intelligence, the power of data lineage, how to deliver an ESG data strategy and, necessarily, regulatory reporting challenges and the data management response, are just some of the key topics that leading capital markets’ participants and innovative solutions vendors will discuss at A-Team Group’s...

EVENT

RegTech Summit New York

Now in its 7th year, the RegTech Summit in NYC will bring together the regtech ecosystem to explore how the North American capital markets financial industry can leverage technology to drive innovation, cut costs and support regulatory change.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2021/2022 – Ninth Edition

Welcome to the ninth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook, a publication dedicated to helping you gain a full understanding of regulations related to your organisation from the details of requirements to best practice implementation. This edition of the handbook includes a focus on regulations being rolled out to bring order and standardisation to...