A-Team Insight Blogs

FRTB Poses Potential Threat to Smaller Regional Banks

Share article

In January the Basel Committee released final revisions to the upcoming Fundamental Review of the Trading Book (FRTB), including a number of modifications to make the regulation more palatable to industry players and a confirmed deadline of January 2022 for initial implementation. Despite its modest revisions, the transformative framework will enforce one of the biggest regulatory trading reviews of the past two decades – and with time running out to effect the required changes, some banks could be at more of a disadvantage than others.

The final incarnation from the Basel Committee includes a number of key changes to the original plan: such as the introduction of a simplified standardised approach for banks with small or non-complex trading portfolios; a clarification of the scope of exposures that are subject to market risk capital requirements; revised treatment of foreign exchange risk, index instruments and options; an updated P&L attribution test; and a relaxation of the requirements for identifying risk factors for internal modelling and non-modellable risk factors.

Yet while these changes should relieve some of the original burden on banks, and could reduce compliance costs – currently estimated at around $5bn, the revised framework is still expected to result in a weighted average increase of about 22% in total market risk capital requirements. While this is a positive reduction from the initial estimates of 40% from the original proposal, it still likely to impose a heavy burden on institutions already chasing to update their systems in time to meet the new requirements.

“If you’re a regional bank or a domestic bank – or even if you’re an international bank that is heavily centred on liquid assets – you’re likely to experience challenges in gathering the required data. In areas where banks don’t trade regularly, they are unlikely to have visibility, therefore they will have to collect an unprecedented quantity of new data in order to run their processes,” explains Kaylash Patel, Head of Enterprise Analytics at Refinitiv. “And banks don’t want to be a data aggregators. They want to be able to focus on what they’re good at, on the businesses that will provide a return on their capital.”

One concerning consequence of this could be the unexpected impact on the competitive landscape, as smaller banks struggle to keep up with their larger peers.

“For a regional bank, they might be very liquid domestically, but they often also provide an international service. If they’re not able to get their processes correct to meet FRTB requirements without attracting punitive capital measures, they could come under real threat from multinationals who are coming at this from a stronger position in terms of enterprise data,” warns Patel.

If smaller banks are not able to get their trade observation data together for internationally traded markets, then they may not to be able to offer that service to their customers. This could in theory lead to a disadvantage compared to multinational banks. There is, therefore, a genuine and identifiable commercial threat to regional banks of not having this process in place early.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Address Emerging Operational Risk and Alleviating Data Blind Spots with AI Powered Risk Management

The digitalisation of financial services is in full flight, as financial institutions strive to offer the same levels of service and improved customer experience that consumer markets have enjoyed for some time. This digitalisation – providing seamless access to appropriate services on demand – requires great emphasis on client data. This changing digital landscape, and...

BLOG

ESMA Releases Long-Awaited Third-Country Draft Rules

ESMA this week published its final report containing draft rules for third-country firms providing investment services in the EU under the MIFIR and MiFID II regimes. The document should provide some long-awaited clarity around the ability of third-country firms to operate in Europe – including, of course, the UK, upon its final departure from the...

EVENT

Data Management Summit London

Now in its 10th year, the Data Management Summit (DMS) in London explores how financial institutions are shifting from defensive to offensive data management strategies, to improve operational efficiency and revenue enhancing opportunities. We’ll be putting the business lens on data and deep diving into the data management capabilities needed to deliver on business outcomes.

GUIDE

Regulatory Data Handbook 2020/2021 – Eighth Edition

This eighth edition of A-Team Group’s Regulatory Data Handbook is a ‘must-have’ for capital markets participants during this period of unprecedented change. Available free of charge, it profiles every regulation that impacts capital markets data management practices giving you: A detailed overview of each regulation with key dates, data and data management implications, links to...