The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The leading knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

CFA Institute Survey Highlights Industry Support for Third Party Valuations

The majority of the members of the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Institute Centre for Financial Market Integrity believe that alternative investment fund managers should be mandated to appoint an independent third party for the valuation of assets, according to a recent survey by the group. The survey, which examines the fund management industry’s views on the requirements of the proposed European Alternative Investment Fund Managers Directive, indicates that 81% of respondents are in favour of mandatory third party valuations provision.

The respondents, which comprise 1,279 CFA members, believe that mandating the appointment of third party providers for valuations is important in order to limit the potential for fraud and ensure that investors’ interests in alternative investment funds are valued properly, as specified by the directive. Moreover, 71% of respondents agreed that an independent third party should retain control over the process to determine a final valuation.

Some of the comments in response to the question whether third party valuations provision should be mandatory are particularly interesting. Some contend that these third party valuations should only be mandatory for Level 2 and 3 assets, as determined by current accounting standards, whereas others believe they should be introduced for all assets. A number note the cost for firms of being compelled by regulation to invest in third party data, especially those at the smaller end of the scale.

“Although auditors as supposed to check valuations, it is not performed frequently, promptly or professionally enough. Any valuation used to calculate published net asset value (NAV) should be fully outsourced to an independent (registered/licensed) third party,” one respondent says. Another few note that the definition of “independent” is in need of clarification in order to prevent any level of confusion or loopholes. “Auditors, for example, are far from independent,” one respondent continues.

The conflict of interest issue is seemingly a significant one for these respondents and should give valuations data providers some leverage in their attempts to market their own data feeds. There definitely seems to be a push towards greater standardisation of pricing data and by offering the same set of data to each individual group, vendors may have the upper hand.

Many respondents also seem to feel regulators should go one step further and audit this valuations data in order to provide an industry benchmark and increase transparency around pricing. This is also likely why so many respondents believe third party providers should control the whole data process: in order to guarantee impartiality, consistency and transparency.

However, given that the directive has currently stalled due to political disagreements across the EU about the details, progress is likely to be slow. In the meantime though, it seems that industry participants are aware of the need for better data around pricing and are willing to face mandatory requirements in the future around this.

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Evolution of data management for the buy-side 2021

The buy-side faced a barrage of regulation in 2020 and is now under pressure to make post-Brexit adjustments and complete LIBOR transition by the end of 2021. To ensure compliance and ease the burden of in-house data management, many firms turned to outsourcing and managed services. But there is more to come, as buy-side firms...

BLOG

GLEIF Moves LEI Uses Cases on from Regulatory Compliance to Digital Identity Products

The Global Legal Entity Identifier Foundation (GLEIF) is extending use cases of the LEI beyond regulatory reporting to solutions initially including digital certificates. The first commercial demonstration of LEIs embedded within digital certificates has been made by the China Financial Certification Authority (CFCA), which has also signed up as a validation agent within the global...

EVENT

RegTech Summit Virtual

The RegTech Summit Virtual is a global online event that brings together an exceptional guest speaker line up of RegTech practitioners, regulators, start-ups and solution providers to collaborate and discuss innovative and effective approaches for building a better regulatory environment.

GUIDE

Entity Data Management Handbook – Third Edition

Welcome to the third edition of the Entity Data Management Handbook which is available for free download. In this updated edition we delve into the role entity data plays in the smooth running of financial institutions and capital markets, the challenges of attaining high quality data, and various aspects, approaches and technologies involved in managing...