The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has imposed more than $63 million in combined penalties on nine investment advisers and three broker-dealers for failing to properly maintain and preserve required electronic communications. One of the firms received leniency for self-reporting, incurring a substantially reduced penalty.
According to SEC findings, the firms and their personnel relied on unapproved methods—often referred to as “off-channel communications”—to conduct business. These communications, which were required to be retained under federal securities laws, were not appropriately recorded or supervised. Supervisors and senior managers were among those who used these methods, underscoring the widespread nature of the violations.Collectively, the firms acknowledged the facts in the SEC’s orders, conceded that their actions violated specific recordkeeping provisions, and agreed to pay civil penalties totalling $63.1 million. Each organization is also subject to cease-and-desist orders covering future violations of recordkeeping rules.
While the fines vary across the firms, the SEC noted one notable exception: PJT Partners LP, which proactively self-reported its shortcomings. As a result, the firm faced a substantially lower penalty of $600,000.
A senior figure at the SEC’s Division of Enforcement, Sanjay Wadhwa, emphasized the importance of accurate recordkeeping for market transparency and integrity. “When firms fail to comply with books and records requirements, the consequences extend far beyond the mere lack of documentation,” he said, pointing to the crucial role these records play in the SEC’s oversight of the markets. Wadhwa also underscored how self-reporting can lead to tangible benefits, noting that PJT Partners’ cooperation was a key factor in determining its reduced penalty.
Below are the main penalty amounts agreed upon by the various entities:
- Blackstone Alternative Credit Advisors LP, along with two related Blackstone entities: $12 million
- Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. L.P.: $11 million
- Charles Schwab & Co., Inc.: $10 million
- Apollo Capital Management L.P.: $8.5 million
- Carlyle Investment Management L.L.C., with two affiliated entities: $8.5 million
- TPG Capital Advisors LLC: $8.5 million
- Santander US Capital Markets LLC: $4 million
- PJT Partners LP (self-reported): $600,000
Legal observers note that these actions reflect the SEC’s continued emphasis on accountability and compliance within financial institutions. “This outcome serves as a clear signal that regulators remain vigilant about safeguarding market data and maintaining transparency,” commented an independent securities law analyst. “Firms should be aware that adopting robust recordkeeping policies isn’t optional; it’s a fundamental requirement.”
Matt Smith, CEO at Integrated surveillance provider, SteelEye puts it more directly noting, “Just two weeks into the new year, the SEC has issued a stark warning to firms with these penalties: lax record-keeping around off-channel communications will not be tolerated. It will come down hard on firms of all sizes and specialties, whether you’re a global tier-one bank, a nimble broker-dealer, or specialist investment advisor.”
The investigations were conducted by multiple SEC offices, with teams led by senior attorneys and supervisors in the agency’s New York Regional Office. Their work underscores the SEC’s ongoing priority to ensure regulated entities fulfil their recordkeeping obligations and maintain proper oversight of communication channels.
Subscribe to our newsletter
