About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Data Poses Challenges for UK Pension Funds’ Climate Compliance

Subscribe to our newsletter

A year after pension funds in the UK were required to begin compiling sustainability reports on their portfolios, a survey has shown that data challenges are making the task difficult.

A shortage of emissions data, inconsistencies in reporting and a reliance on estimates are making it almost impossible for funds that hold about £2.2 trillion in assets to produce accurate reports on their investments’ sustainability, according to the findings of the report by Pensions for Purpose (PFP).

The industry group’s report, based on interviews with pension funds and schemes, including those of AXA, IBM, NatWest and Royal Mail, warned that the disclosure difficulties would be amplified when the Department for Work and Pensions’ (DWP) regulation is extended.

“It’s a work in progress,” PFP project manager Karen Shackleton told ESG Insight. “And I don’t think we’re there yet.”

Funds Interviewed

Since 2021, the DWP has required pension funds to submit sustainability reports based on the disclosure framework set out by the Taskforce for Nature-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). It states that each fund must publish its first report within seven months of the end of the scheme year that began when the regulation came into force. As that date was October 1, 2021, the first reports are beginning to see the light of day.

The funds were asked to gauge their reaction to the compliance process. Data availability and quality accounted for a large part of their disquiet. While PFP accepts that the data issues couldn’t be expected to be eliminated in the first year of the regulation, they nevertheless posed a danger of creating an erroneous “baseline” against which funds would gauge their portfolios’ climate goals and shape their investment plans.

“Funds are having to estimate a lot, which makes it difficult to make decisions because estimations are inherently flawed and data based on that going forward might be skewed,” PFP research analyst Cameron Turner told ESG Insight.

PFP’s survey was based on interviews with corporate pension funds – defined benefit and defined contribution – local government pension schemes, investment consultants and asset managers. Participants at a Pensions for Purpose Paris Alignment Forum all-stakeholder event last year were also consulted.

Data Inconsistencies

Turner said that respondents had complained that data gathered by asset managers from investee companies was often inconsistent because it had been based on different reporting methodologies. This made comparisons difficult, Turner said.

Shackleton said that investment managers bore some responsibility for the data inconsistencies, as they hadn’t always fully declared the level of disclosure by the companies within their portfolios. They were not necessarily withholding information, Shackleton said, it was was more a case that investment managers may be unaware of the portfolio’s entire performance metrics.

“Comparing companies is exactly what the pension fund wants to do,” she said. “They want to aggregate this data, to come up with a portfolio number.”

Scope 3 Disclosures

Shackleton expressed particular concern about data on private companies, which aren’t required to report sustainability metrics under the regulation. This will have a significant impact on funds’ ability to report on their portfolios’ Scope 3 emissions, which will be expected in coming years.

“There are some huge challenges ahead in terms of private markets data – getting that verified, robust and comparable across the industry,” she said. “My concern is around how we cope with the potential for double counting, when Scope 3 really does roll out. You need a rigorous process to deal with that.”

Shackleton said that PFP expected tightening regulations would help solve many of the data problems, especially when organisations like hers were pushing for better disclosures. And for all the funds’ concern about data, the survey showed overwhelming support for the process of compiling climate performance metrics.

“I think pretty much uniformly they all said that pension funds should still be doing this because if you learn in the process and, in time, we think the data will improve to the point where it can drive investment strategy,” Shackleton said.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content


Recorded Webinar: From Data to Impact: Empowering Asset Managers and Owners with ESG Solutions for Net Zero Transformation

As asset managers and owners embark on their net zero journey, aligning with the Net Zero Asset Managers (NZAM) and Net Zero Asset Owner Alliance (NZAOA) initiatives, they will encounter various challenges. One of these revolves around effectively managing and using data, as the volume and complexity of data related to emissions, sustainability, and environmental...


Novata Carbon Navigator Aims to Reduce Cost and Complexity of Disclosures

Novata, a fast-growing start-up that is providing ESG data solutions to private market investors, has unveiled a carbon-tracking tool that’s devised to be affordable and user friendly to even the smallest portfolio company. The New York-based technology company’s Carbon Navigator helps companies and private equity general partners (GPs) calculate their carbon emissions and compare their performance against...


Data Management Summit London

Now in its 14th year, the Data Management Summit (DMS) in London brings together the European capital markets enterprise data management community, to explore how data strategy is evolving to drive business outcomes and speed to market in changing times.


Entity Data Management Handbook

Following on from the success of our Regulatory Data Handbook, A-Team Group is pleased to introduce its new Entity Data Management Handbook which is available for free download. This Handbook is the ultimate guide to all things entity data: Why Entity Data is important A full review of Legal Entity Identifiers (LEIs) Where they came...