About a-team Marketing Services
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry
The knowledge platform for the financial technology industry

A-Team Insight Blogs

Andrew’s Blog – The Problem with Standards?

Subscribe to our newsletter

Every few years I feel the compulsion to write a rant – known these days as a blog – about the problem with standards, and in particular standards relating to financial information. Usually, this is sparked by some new initiative to get competing vendors to live together peacefully so the marketplace can reap the benefits of streamlined systems communication and reduced opportunity to price gauging.

The target of my angst in this department is recurring: too many standards means no standard at all.

But my recent and ongoing delvings into the world of risk technology for our sister publication – Risk-Technology.net – have unveiled a new (to me) twist to the debate, which may go some way toward explaining why establishing a credible data standard for any aspect of the financial trade lifecycle is akin to pulling teeth.

The reason is quite simple and it’s this: the client community doesn’t want standards.

Banks, brokers, asset managers and other consumers of market, reference and other financial information services, this argument goes, believe they are better qualified to scrub and normalise vendor-supplied data than the suppliers of that data are themselves. And with some justification. Vendors of most types of financial information are not financial markets practitioners, and as such don’t have the downstream processes that would give them the expertise needed to scrub unclean data properly to make it fit for purpose.

Assuming this is, indeed, the case, most practitioners would prefer to receive unclean data from their suppliers, since they understand the processes involved in making that data fit for purpose and – crucially – see those processes as a competitive advantage.

In other words, these practitioners reckon they can clean the third-party data they need better than anyone else, and would prefer to keep this perceived advantage in place.

Now, detractors will rapidly point out – so, don’t feel you need to – that given the huge amount of resources they ‘waste’ on scrubbing external data sources, market practitioners will welcome any standards initiative aimed at streamlining their processes. Clearly, that will be the case for many, if not most financial institutions.

But this data normalisation as competitive advantage argument has some credence. Increasingly, applications providers are including a kind of data normalisation toolkit as an adjunct to their core system, perhaps in recognition of the fact that client organisations want more control over the way they normalise data before it is consumed by key applications.

Certainly, garbage in, garbage out is a widely heard mantra in the risk community. With so many initiatives in data standards ongoing right now, perhaps the question is not whether there are too many standards but rather that they are just not wanted.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Related content

WEBINAR

Recorded Webinar: Detecting and preventing market abuse

Market abuse – unlawful disclosure of inside information, insider trading, circular trading, “pump and dump” schemes, etc. – poses significant threats to the integrity of capital markets. In 2024, global trading house Trafigura agreed to pay a $55 million fine to the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) for trading with non-public information, manipulating a...

BLOG

Validating GenAI Models in Finance: A Q&A with Chandrakant Maheshwari on Risk, Governance, and the Rise of Agentic AI

At a recent RegTech Insight Advisory Board session, a discussion with Chandrakant on generative AI (GenAI) and model risk management underscored the need to cut through the hype and myths around GenAI and emerging agentic AI in regulated markets. This Q&A is the result. It examines why traditional model validation techniques—ROC curves and confusion matrices—can’t...

EVENT

TradingTech Summit London

Now in its 14th year the TradingTech Summit London brings together the European trading technology capital markets industry and examines the latest changes and innovations in trading technology and explores how technology is being deployed to create an edge in sell side and buy side capital markets financial institutions.

GUIDE

AI in Capital Markets: Practical Insight for a Transforming Industry – Free Handbook

AI is no longer on the horizon – it’s embedded in the infrastructure of modern capital markets. But separating real impact from inflated promises requires a grounded, practical understanding. The AI in Capital Markets Handbook 2025 provides exactly that. Designed for data-driven professionals across the trade life-cycle, compliance, infrastructure, and strategy, this handbook goes beyond...